Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Discussions on Wikimedia governance
User avatar
tarantino
Habitué
Posts: 4793
kołdry
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 7:19 pm

Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by tarantino » Sun Nov 10, 2019 3:17 am

16:14, 7 November 2019 JCabanero (WMF) talk contribs changed status for global account "User:VDcosta (WMF)@global": set locked; unset (none) (No longer employed with the Foundation)

Just nine months ago:
The Wikimedia Foundation is excited to announce the appointment of Valerie D’Costa as Chief of Community Engagement. Valerie joins the Foundation after a decade at the World Bank Group, including nine years as leader of InfoDev, an initiative to facilitate sustainable development through access to data and information. Altogether, Valerie brings more than 25 years of experience launching and growing international initiatives in the developing world.
As usual, they're excited to announce their new hire, but everyone other than staff are left guessing why they are no longer excited.

User avatar
Osborne
Habitué
Posts: 1259
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 8:29 pm

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Osborne » Sun Nov 10, 2019 3:49 am

"joins the Wikimedia Foundation after over a decade of serving at the World Bank Group"
Did not last long...
9 months is more than enough to see through the false image created by the wmf and wikipedia. Anybody with a conscience realizes nothing good can come out of this and leaves or it's peers realize a person with conscience is not suitable for the job.
Last edited by Osborne on Sun Nov 10, 2019 4:06 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Vigilant
Sonny, I've got a whole theme park full of red delights for you.
Posts: 31795
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:16 pm
Wikipedia User: Vigilant
Wikipedia Review Member: Vigilant

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Vigilant » Sun Nov 10, 2019 3:53 am

https://wikimediafoundation.org/profile/valerie-dcosta/
Valerie D’Costa is the Chief of Community Engagement with the Wikimedia Foundation and leads the organization’s Community Engagement department and efforts to support Wikimedia’s global community of contributors and affiliates.

A native of Singapore, Valerie joined the Wikimedia Foundation after a decade at the World Bank Group, where she was charged with leading international initiatives to support communities of entrepreneurs in emerging markets around the world. She led the Bank’s Women’s Economic Empowerment Program, where she helped female entrepreneurs and women-led businesses in developing countries grow and gain access to new market opportunities. Prior to that, she was the Director of infoDev, a Bank program that supports innovation hubs and technology incubators for entrepreneurs in developing countries. Before joining the World Bank, Valerie spent 15 years working with the government of Singapore on issues of international information and communications technology (ICT) policy and trade.

Valerie has worked her whole career in the intersection between technology and improving people’s lives around the world. She brings a deep understanding of the importance of local ownership, cross-cultural communication, and program sustainability. She emphasizes the importance of collaboration and partnership with local communities in designing and implementing programs and approaches, believing that local partners best understand their own needs and aspirations.

Valerie received her Bachelor of Laws from the National University of Singapore and her Master of Laws from University College London. She has also received an executive MBA certification from the University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business and she is certified by the International Coach Federation and Georgetown University School of Continuing Studies as an executive leadership coach She is an avid painter and hiker, and she believes Singapore food is the best in the world.
Her work experience reads like the very definition of diversity hire.

http://www.infodev.org/valerie-dcosta-farewell
Farewell from Valerie D'Costa

Dear friends, colleagues, innovators, partners, policymakers, investors, researchers, technology leaders, entrepreneurs, and start-ups:

My time at infoDev has come to a close. I will be moving on to other duties at the World Bank. I have a heavy heart leaving the vibrant and evolving global innovation and entrepreneurship community that I have called home for the past seven years. Yet, I realize the world grows smaller every day, so I am sure our paths will continue to cross in the future.

infoDev has played a remarkable and much-needed role in development. The mission of helping growth enterprises and incubating innovative startups to market is a worthy one. infoDev has been able to pilot a number of new and untested ideas with the support and commitment of the World Bank Group and its donors. It has pushed the envelope to see where development impact lies. I have seen representatives of the public, private, academic and civil society sectors work together collaboratively in many countries, with infoDev facilitating the process. These multi-stakeholder efforts - while not always easy – have been rewarding and have resulted in sustainable solutions.

A year ago, we decided to regularly profile some of the entrepreneur success stories from across our global network, so that we can put faces to the names of the best and brightest future business leaders. They have been a source of particular pride for me. I’ve been so gratified to see these entrepreneurs pitch their ideas, gain international attention, attract significant investment, win global innovation awards, engage in dialogue with princes and presidents, put their solutions into the market, and seek out new business and growth opportunities.

As our innovation and entrepreneurship networks continue to organically grow across the world, I hope you will all continue to partner actively with infoDev, and count on its support. Leading infoDev has been a rich, rewarding, successful, challenging, and very joyful experience. I thank the dedicated team I’ve led for their passion and commitment.

Most of all, I want to thank all of you in our global community for the pleasure of knowing and working with you.

You have my very best wishes for health, peace, and every success for the future.

Sincerely,

Valerie D’Costa
Tell me that this is not a giant pants load of do-nothing speak.



I wonder if the WMF was too weird and incompetent for her or vice versa.
Hello, John. John, hello. You're the one soul I would come up here to collect myself.

User avatar
Poetlister
Genius
Posts: 25599
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 8:15 pm
Nom de plume: Poetlister
Location: London, living in a similar way
Contact:

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Poetlister » Sun Nov 10, 2019 11:25 am

My reading is that she was reasonably competent but thwarted in her attempts to do her job by the incompetence of the WMF. She must have wept over Framgate.
"The higher we soar the smaller we appear to those who cannot fly" - Nietzsche

User avatar
Osborne
Habitué
Posts: 1259
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 8:29 pm

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Osborne » Sun Nov 10, 2019 11:44 am

Poetlister wrote:My reading is that she was reasonably competent but thwarted in her attempts to do her job by the incompetence of the WMF. She must have wept over Framgate.
Is incompetence the right word? In my enlightening discussions with WMF employees, I see some of them are very competent in talking their way out of any kind of responsibility or hard work and also very competent in protecting their position, despite not doing their job.

User avatar
DanMurphy
Habitué
Posts: 3153
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 11:58 pm
Wikipedia User: Dan Murphy
Wikipedia Review Member: DanMurphy

Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by DanMurphy » Sun Nov 17, 2019 12:01 am

Looks like Val D’Costa, chief community engagement officer for a whopping 8 months, has been fired.
What comes next for Community Engagement

I’ll be direct — we are making changes to the CE department structure.

We will not be starting a search for a new Chief of Community Engagement. Instead, over the course of the next few weeks, the seven teams currently within the Community Engagement (CE) department will be integrated into the Foundation’s other departments. By January, all of the teams will have joined their new departments, and “Community Engagement” will no longer be a standalone department.

The teams currently in CE will be integrated with other Foundation departments aligned with executive leadership goals and based on their scope and focus, as well as how they might grow in the future. Some of these alignments are intuitive, such as Trust & Safety returning to the Legal department; others might not be immediately apparent.
ADDING: I see the D'Costa firing was brought up here a week ago. Probably best to just fold this into that.

User avatar
Vigilant
Sonny, I've got a whole theme park full of red delights for you.
Posts: 31795
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:16 pm
Wikipedia User: Vigilant
Wikipedia Review Member: Vigilant

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Vigilant » Sun Nov 17, 2019 12:35 am

https://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/w ... 93816.html
Hello everyone,

I am writing to let you know that Val D’Costa, Chief Community Engagement
Officer, is leaving the Wikimedia Foundation. I also want to share some
changes we’re making around how the Foundation organizes staff in the
Community Engagement department.

Val joined us last January, bringing nearly three decades of experience
launching and growing international initiatives in emerging markets. With
the Wikimedia 2030 movement strategy as a guide, Val and her team drafted
an ambitious new vision for the work of Community Engagement—focused on
decentralization of power and resources, safe and welcoming spaces,
equitable collaboration, increased language and cultural fluency, dedicated
programs for groups such as women and young people, and expansive
partnerships in service of free knowledge.

With this vision in hand, Val and I both see this as the right juncture for
her to move on to her next professional challenge. While she will be
leaving the position of Chief of Community Engagement, she will remain on
as a consultant to me for a brief period.

I am deeply appreciative of Val’s time with us at the Foundation and want
to thank her for the contributions she has made to the Wikimedia movement.
She has been a passionate and persuasive advocate for our mission and
pushed us to expand our vision of what could be possible for our movement.
I wish her the absolute best in what she does next.

*== What comes next for Community Engagement ==*

I'll be direct -- we are making changes to the CE department structure.

We will not be starting a search for a new Chief of Community Engagement.
Instead, over the course of the next few weeks, the seven teams currently
within the Community Engagement (CE) department will be integrated into the
Foundation’s other departments. By January, all of the teams will have
joined their new departments, and “Community Engagement” will no longer be
a standalone department.

The teams currently in CE will be integrated with other Foundation
departments aligned with executive leadership goals and based on their
scope and focus, as well as how they might grow in the future. Some of
these alignments are intuitive, such as Trust & Safety returning to the
Legal department; others might not be immediately apparent.

*== What does this mean for your work? ==*

Although we have a good sense of which teams will integrate with which
departments, we are still meeting with the individual teams to work on the
specific details of the transition. Our focus is on continuity for existing
community programs and support for Foundation staff in making this change.
You may hear from staff seeking input on those arrangements, and I want to
thank you in advance for any feedback you may have.

We expect to wrap up these conversations in early December, to begin
transitions in mid-December, and for the transitions to be completed by the
beginning of January, at which point we’ll be able to share an overview of
the new arrangements in full.

The work of the Community Engagement teams will remain the same throughout
this period of transition. For example, if you need something from Trust &
Safety or Community Resources, they’ll continue to be here to work with
you. If you have a project or program underway with a CE team or staff
member, that work will also continue. If you have any questions, please
feel free to reach out to Greg Varnum at gvarnum at wikimedia.org or leave
your question in Wikimedia Space [1] and we’ll make sure we find an answer
to your question.

*== Why are we making this change? ==*

The Community Engagement department has grown and evolved since it was
created in 2015. We have brought in people with an increasingly diverse set
of skills and backgrounds and introduced new support for additional
languages, geographies, and areas of work, such as community health.

While this has helped the Foundation come a long way in addressing the
needs of the movement, it has also created complexity. The breadth of
activities and competencies now supported by the department is quite
large—today, we have people working on issues as diverse as GLAM collection
management, participatory grantmaking, and contributor safety—and
increasingly, across many geographies, cultures, and languages.

This has created challenges for how we effectively coordinate such a range
of specializations, how we assess their efficacy and impact against our
mission. At the same time, as the Foundation has grown, we have developed
capacities in other departments who will be good partners to those serving
our community mission.

In making these changes, we see an opportunity to align the functions of
the Foundation with the future of the mission and movement, and better
serve long-time contributors and emerging communities alike. Over time, we
anticipate these new arrangements will deepen the understanding of
community efforts among all Foundation staff and programs, integrate
community perspective across program design and support, and open up space
for bold and fresh thinking about how to move our movement forward.

*== What about the future? ==*

Some people may be wondering, what does this mean for the proposed work in
the Annual or Medium Term plans, or the planned restructure of the
Community Engagement department to a new regional approach?

We remain fully committed to the work and goals of the Medium Term Plan.
For example, although Val was not able to attend Indaba to celebrate with
the African community, our COO and Deputy General Counsel, Janeen Uzzell
and Tony Sebro, both attended.

The planned restructure and expansion of CE was intended to help us support
the community in achieving these goals. This includes the MTP’s focus on
building a thriving movement, increasing community health and diversity,
and growing among new languages, regions, and audiences. We set these goals
as part of our interpretation of the Movement Strategy, and they will
remain our focus for the medium term.

I still believe we need to make many of these changes, as well as be
prepared for further changes that may arise from the recommendations of the
Movement Strategy Working Groups. We see a future that could include
improved regional support, and expanded programmatic support for emerging
communities, whether those are new languages, geographies, or areas of
practice.

However, we are putting those plans on hold for the next few weeks, while
we focus is on supporting the existing teams through this transition. I
want us to make sure that goes well, before turning our attention to the
future. That said, I fully expect to resume work on how we expand our
support for these critical new areas in the first quarter of the new
calendar year.

== Final thoughts ==

I want to be absolutely clear that these changes are in no way an
indication that the Foundation is decreasing our commitment to support for
the movement. I hope you see how this offers an opportunity to do the exact
opposite—to set us up to support the movement in the best way we can.

For those with an interest in Wikimedia history, it’s worth noting that the
Foundation has taken many different shapes over the years. In 2014, teams
focused on community support were embedded in other departments. At the
time, we were much smaller, and our ability to truly engage with the full
breadth of the movement was more limited. In 2019, the community engagement
teams are better resourced, more global, and more representative of the
movement (although there’s always space for continued improvement).

We see this as the right moment to integrate the perspectives, experiences,
and skills of these teams across the Foundation, ensuring that support for
the movement is woven into all the Foundation’s work. As Wikimedians, we
know change is a constant—and it is through change that we often do our
best work, solve our hardest problems, and find our new path forward. Thank
you in advance as we take this next step to support the future of our
movement.

Sincerely,
Katherine
Ten pounds of shit in a five pound bag.
Hello, John. John, hello. You're the one soul I would come up here to collect myself.

User avatar
Vigilant
Sonny, I've got a whole theme park full of red delights for you.
Posts: 31795
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:16 pm
Wikipedia User: Vigilant
Wikipedia Review Member: Vigilant

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Vigilant » Sun Nov 17, 2019 12:49 am

Hello, John. John, hello. You're the one soul I would come up here to collect myself.

User avatar
Vigilant
Sonny, I've got a whole theme park full of red delights for you.
Posts: 31795
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:16 pm
Wikipedia User: Vigilant
Wikipedia Review Member: Vigilant

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Vigilant » Sun Nov 17, 2019 12:54 am

Hello, John. John, hello. You're the one soul I would come up here to collect myself.

Beeblebrox
Habitué
Posts: 3845
Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2016 9:30 pm
Wikipedia User: Just Step Sideways
Location: The end of the road, Alaska

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Beeblebrox » Sun Nov 17, 2019 1:59 am

If I'm reading this right, Maher is saying that they followed D’Costa's recommendations, and now there's no department for them to head? That actually doesn't sound like a stupid idea, at least at a glance. Having different community engagement people for different areas of the Foundation seems reasonable. In particular, putting T&S under legal's thumb does not strike me as a bad idea at all. I doubt legal would've greenlit the Framban.

I'll will, however note that I've not yet read Vigilant's linked email threads so maybe I'm missing something obvious.
information is not knowledge, knowledge is not wisdom

User avatar
Vigilant
Sonny, I've got a whole theme park full of red delights for you.
Posts: 31795
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 8:16 pm
Wikipedia User: Vigilant
Wikipedia Review Member: Vigilant

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Vigilant » Sun Nov 17, 2019 2:17 am

If I were going to guess, I'd bet that D'Costa represented a threat to Maher's leadership and so dear Katherine iced her and blew up her department to disperse D'Costa's partisans.
Hello, John. John, hello. You're the one soul I would come up here to collect myself.

User avatar
Randy from Boise
Been Around Forever
Posts: 12245
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2012 2:32 am
Wikipedia User: Carrite
Wikipedia Review Member: Timbo
Actual Name: Tim Davenport
Nom de plume: T. Chandler
Location: Boise, Idaho

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Randy from Boise » Sun Nov 17, 2019 3:49 am

Beeblebrox wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 1:59 am
Having different community engagement people for different areas of the Foundation seems reasonable. In particular, putting T&S under legal's thumb does not strike me as a bad idea at all. I doubt legal would've greenlit the Framban.
They certainly wouldn't have greenlit the Brillban.

RfB

User avatar
DHeyward
Gregarious
Posts: 550
Joined: Mon Feb 24, 2014 5:52 am
Wikipedia User: DHeyward

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by DHeyward » Sun Nov 17, 2019 6:08 am

I think it was a shock. Coming from orgs like World Bank where the org controls the flow of money to the community and community conforms to whatever World Bank, WMF relies on the community for everything. It wouldn't surprise me if the T&S Fram fiasco was tacitly approved by a new "Community Engagement" safe space initiative. Realizing the inmates run the asylum must have been quite the shock.

User avatar
Pudeo
Regular
Posts: 306
Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2018 8:14 pm

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Pudeo » Sun Nov 17, 2019 10:51 am

DHeyward wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 6:08 am
I think it was a shock. Coming from orgs like World Bank where the org controls the flow of money to the community and community conforms to whatever World Bank, WMF relies on the community for everything. It wouldn't surprise me if the T&S Fram fiasco was tacitly approved by a new "Community Engagement" safe space initiative. Realizing the inmates run the asylum must have been quite the shock.
I was thinking about something similar. When someone like that joins Wikimedia, they probably expect to be in a powerful role influencing one of the world's most important information sources. But because they've never edited Wikipedia, they don't know that the WMF's role is meaningless except for running the donations. The Fram situation could be seen as trying to exert the influence they'd want to have.

User avatar
Osborne
Habitué
Posts: 1259
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 8:29 pm

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Osborne » Sun Nov 17, 2019 2:29 pm

DHeyward wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 6:08 am
Realizing the inmates run the asylum must have been quite the shock.
That's what I imagine her experience could have been. Seeing her in TED talk, I had the impression she is too well-intended and not ruthless enough to have a chance at the WMF.
Pudeo wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 10:51 am
When someone like that joins Wikimedia, they probably expect to be in a powerful role influencing one of the world's most important information sources. But because they've never edited Wikipedia, they don't know that the WMF's role is meaningless except for running the donations.
And that.

User avatar
Randy from Boise
Been Around Forever
Posts: 12245
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2012 2:32 am
Wikipedia User: Carrite
Wikipedia Review Member: Timbo
Actual Name: Tim Davenport
Nom de plume: T. Chandler
Location: Boise, Idaho

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Randy from Boise » Sun Nov 17, 2019 3:58 pm

Pudeo wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 10:51 am
When someone like that joins Wikimedia, they probably expect to be in a powerful role influencing one of the world's most important information sources. But because they've never edited Wikipedia, they don't know that the WMF's role is meaningless except for running the donations....
....and distributing the swag.

RfB

User avatar
Eric Corbett
Retired
Posts: 2066
Joined: Fri Aug 03, 2018 5:38 pm
Wikipedia User: Eric Corbett
Actual Name: Eric Corbett

Re: Maher makes Community Engagement department go "poof."

Unread post by Eric Corbett » Sun Nov 17, 2019 6:17 pm

Beeblebrox wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 1:59 am
If I'm reading this right, Maher is saying that they followed D’Costa's recommendations, and now there's no department for them to head? That actually doesn't sound like a stupid idea, at least at a glance. Having different community engagement people for different areas of the Foundation seems reasonable. In particular, putting T&S under legal's thumb does not strike me as a bad idea at all. I doubt legal would've greenlit the Framban.
It makes little sense to hire someone with the intention of firing them a few months later. If the position was always meant to be a temporary one, she would have hired as a consultant.

User avatar
Moral Hazard
Super Genius
Posts: 3401
Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2015 4:46 pm
Wikipedia User: Kiefer.Wolfowitz
Nom de plume: Kiefer Wolfowitz
Contact:

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Moral Hazard » Sun Nov 17, 2019 7:29 pm

Would anybody competent wish to spend her days working with Karen Brown and Sherry Snyder (the only two people listed with her on CE)?
Kiefer.Wolfowitz (T-C-L)
“Arguing with anonymous strangers on the Internet is a sucker's game because they almost always turn out to be—or to be indistinguishable from—self-righteous sixteen-year-olds possessing infinite amounts of free time.”
Neal Stephenson (T-H-L) Cryptonomicon

User avatar
eagle
Eagle
Posts: 1254
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 12:26 pm

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by eagle » Sun Nov 17, 2019 9:16 pm

I sense that currently, Community Engagement spends a great deal of time in San Francisco addressing English Wikipedia and other large language encyclopedias. If, heaven forbid, the new 2030 proposals go through, they will find native speakers and base them in cities around the word so that those WMF can help ensure that underrepresented voices get to tell their stories on hundreds of different language wikipedias. Better to spread the resources across the globe than to assure that the flagship product has any vitality or viability.

User avatar
Randy from Boise
Been Around Forever
Posts: 12245
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2012 2:32 am
Wikipedia User: Carrite
Wikipedia Review Member: Timbo
Actual Name: Tim Davenport
Nom de plume: T. Chandler
Location: Boise, Idaho

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Randy from Boise » Mon Nov 18, 2019 7:58 pm

eagle wrote:
Sun Nov 17, 2019 9:16 pm
I sense that currently, Community Engagement spends a great deal of time in San Francisco addressing English Wikipedia and other large language encyclopedias. If, heaven forbid, the new 2030 proposals go through, they will find native speakers and base them in cities around the word so that those WMF can help ensure that underrepresented voices get to tell their stories on hundreds of different language wikipedias. Better to spread the resources across the globe than to assure that the flagship product has any vitality or viability.
Dunno, they're gonna waste 93.8% of the money they take in anyway — better to squander it around the globe with minimum impact on En-WP.

Kalmyk-Wikipedia needs love, too.

RfB

User avatar
Poetlister
Genius
Posts: 25599
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 8:15 pm
Nom de plume: Poetlister
Location: London, living in a similar way
Contact:

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Poetlister » Mon Nov 18, 2019 9:26 pm

They probably imagine that ENWP can look after itself. The quantity is fine and who cares about the quality?
"The higher we soar the smaller we appear to those who cannot fly" - Nietzsche

User avatar
Eric Corbett
Retired
Posts: 2066
Joined: Fri Aug 03, 2018 5:38 pm
Wikipedia User: Eric Corbett
Actual Name: Eric Corbett

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Eric Corbett » Tue Nov 19, 2019 11:46 pm

Poetlister wrote:
Mon Nov 18, 2019 9:26 pm
They probably imagine that ENWP can look after itself. The quantity is fine and who cares about the quality?
That's very obviously true.

User avatar
Bezdomni
Habitué
Posts: 2964
Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2016 9:07 pm
Wikipedia User: RosasHills
Location: Monster Vainglory ON (.. party HQ ..)
Contact:

Re: Valerie D’Costa out as Chief of Community Engagement

Unread post by Bezdomni » Fri Nov 22, 2019 8:38 pm

on the MoveCom!
los auberginos

Post Reply