Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, free!
-
- Majordomo
- Posts: 13410
- kołdry
- Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 5:07 pm
- Wikipedia User: Thekohser
- Wikipedia Review Member: thekohser
- Actual Name: Gregory Kohs
- Location: United States
Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, free!
I really didn't notice this when our own Andreas Kolbe wrote about it, or when Beutler gave it a send-up. I think it merits a discussion thread.
The Italian Wikipedia article Telecom Italia was completely refurbished by six undergraduates at Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, in a cooperative project between Telecom Italia and (I presume) a professor at the university, with guidance from Wikimedia Italia's Cristian Consonni.
Is this the future of "paid editing"? Broker college students as unpaid interns?
The Italian Wikipedia article Telecom Italia was completely refurbished by six undergraduates at Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, in a cooperative project between Telecom Italia and (I presume) a professor at the university, with guidance from Wikimedia Italia's Cristian Consonni.
Is this the future of "paid editing"? Broker college students as unpaid interns?
"...making nonsensical connections and culminating in feigned surprise, since 2006..."
-
- Gregarious
- Posts: 650
- Joined: Mon Apr 21, 2014 1:29 pm
- Wikipedia Review Member: Text
- Actual Name: Anonyymi
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
They get paid in free bananas at lunchtimeIs this the future of "paid editing"? Broker college students as unpaid interns?
-
- Denizen
- Posts: 6953
- Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 2:05 am
- Wikipedia User: Jayen466
- Wikipedia Review Member: HRIP7
- Actual Name: Andreas Kolbe
- Location: UK
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
This thread is discussed on an Italian blog here.
-
- Genius
- Posts: 25599
- Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 8:15 pm
- Nom de plume: Poetlister
- Location: London, living in a similar way
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
If they weren't paid, it's not paid editing. That's an interesting problem to be sorted out!
"The higher we soar the smaller we appear to those who cannot fly" - Nietzsche
-
- Majordomo
- Posts: 13410
- Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 5:07 pm
- Wikipedia User: Thekohser
- Wikipedia Review Member: thekohser
- Actual Name: Gregory Kohs
- Location: United States
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
The commenters seem to be wringing their hands in anguish.HRIP7 wrote:This thread is discussed on an Italian blog here.
"...making nonsensical connections and culminating in feigned surprise, since 2006..."
-
- Posts: 10891
- Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2012 11:32 pm
- Location: hell
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
Hah. This crap is a routine, almost daily, occurrence, and even when pushed in their faces, they refuse to believe it.
Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. And no one is checking. Only when an editor who gives a damn stumbles across it and dares to fix it (or someone posts it on this forum and embarrasses the "Wikipedians") is such a problem article likely to be repaired. "Unimportant" articles usually are never repaired otherwise.not only the changes could easily have been canceled, but the students have explained what they were doing in their user pages
-
- Gregarious
- Posts: 650
- Joined: Mon Apr 21, 2014 1:29 pm
- Wikipedia Review Member: Text
- Actual Name: Anonyymi
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
"Who should have rewritten the page about Telecom? Someone working for Telecom? Of course
not. There could be a risk to have a hagiographic page. After all the guidelines don't support pages
written by people with a conflict of interest. Have these students gained something from working
on those pages, even if didn't earn any money? Yes, possibly, because they were following a
course about communication sciences and that could have helped them."
"The real question is: Has Wikipedia gained something from all this? The answer is "Yes". There are now more data, information, sources, and users can now know more things (mot "different things", but "things"). Isn't this the objective of an encyclopedia?"
Eh, whatever. The important thing for .mau. is that Wikipedia "gains something".
And of course Tavecchio has a BLP http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Tavecchio
But, I assure you, this banana icon was not made specifically to refer to that incident that involved him
not. There could be a risk to have a hagiographic page. After all the guidelines don't support pages
written by people with a conflict of interest. Have these students gained something from working
on those pages, even if didn't earn any money? Yes, possibly, because they were following a
course about communication sciences and that could have helped them."
"The real question is: Has Wikipedia gained something from all this? The answer is "Yes". There are now more data, information, sources, and users can now know more things (mot "different things", but "things"). Isn't this the objective of an encyclopedia?"
Eh, whatever. The important thing for .mau. is that Wikipedia "gains something".
And of course Tavecchio has a BLP http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Tavecchio
But, I assure you, this banana icon was not made specifically to refer to that incident that involved him
-
- Denizen
- Posts: 6953
- Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2012 2:05 am
- Wikipedia User: Jayen466
- Wikipedia Review Member: HRIP7
- Actual Name: Andreas Kolbe
- Location: UK
Re: Telecom Italia gets students to write corporate bio, fre
Well, this is a two-edged sword. We often criticise the English Wikipedia for being overly persecutory of companies (which drives paid editing underground and/or leads to hatchet jobs), and praise the German Wikipedia for its policy of registered, openly disclosed company accounts editing with full transparency.
Of course there are potential problems with an initiative like this one in the Italian Wikipedia, but on the whole I prefer this approach to the one espoused by the English Wikipedia – as long as it's made fully transparent to the reader.
Of course there are potential problems with an initiative like this one in the Italian Wikipedia, but on the whole I prefer this approach to the one espoused by the English Wikipedia – as long as it's made fully transparent to the reader.