mac wrote:roger_pearse wrote:
Why be gratuitously rude?
To fit in.
I do think it is more than that, as I said above, part of the
raison d'etre for a certain class of Wikipidiot is to "kick the lower lifeforms", by which I mean construct a small part of the Wiki-world in which one appears powerful and respected. This is the
Napolean complex (T-H-L) of Wikipedia. People who are not powerful or respected in the real world -- because they are children, because they are disabled or ill, because they are ugly, stupid, and/or weak, or for whatever reason -- will seek out imaginary environments in which they can, in some small way, be in control.
This plays out at multiple levels in Wikipedia. At the top of the heap is Jimbo, a small man who is also not very tall. He told stories about his stock-trading acumen that appear to have been less than true. He started a porn company through which he could be seen with buxom women. Now through Wikipedia he can play the role of a master of the digital universe, provided he relegates Larry Sanger and others to the background.
Go down a level. Remember
Cool Hand Luke (T-C-L) (aka
Frank Bednarz)? He was a wiki-wheel running around avenging the wiki, playing pretend wiki-lawyer on Arbcom and so forth -- until he graduated from law school and got a job as a real lawyer. Now he is seldom on Wikipedia, or uses his "power" there. Similarly with
Newyorkbrad (T-C-L) (
Ira Matetsky). Brad/Ira is admitted to the New York and Federal Bars, yet since he joined his current firm (as a litigator) in 2004, his presence in the federal case registry has been remarkably light. Perhaps he keeps in legal "shape" by playing the role of Supreme Court Justice on Wikipedia.
Go down another level and you have your random power-pushing admins, too many to mention individually.
And at the lowest level you have Wikipidiots like GWickwire, with little or no real power or influence on the wiki (or in real life, most likely), who are reduced to the wiki equivalent of kicking the dog. I don't think they do it to "fit in" (though "all the big kids are doing it" is a tried and tested excuse for bad behaviour) so much as simply because they can.