SamwiseGSix' explanation for the Herbermann "quote":This is about making stuff up. See [12]. Seen Talk:Anthroposophy, wherein others made the same point (look for posts of 1 November 2023), I came to believe that most citations by SamwiseGSix are phony. Meaning the WP:RS fail to WP:V the claims they're WP:CITED for. SamwiseGSix cited a bunch of sources, putting his own opinions in their mouth. He might not understand what we mean by WP:V, but that's not a reason for allowing his citations to stay in the article.
Herbermann, Charles George (2015-10-02). The Catholic Encyclopedia. Arkose Press. ISBN 978-1-343-86075-9. is an 80-pages booklet. It is not a 16-volumes encyclopedia. So, it does not have a volume 13, nor a volume 14. tgeorgescu (talk) 13:56, 10 January 2024 (UTC)
BTW, The Christian Community (T-H-L) was founded in 1922, the Catholic Encyclopedia (T-H-L) was published 1907-1912 (plus an index volume 1914) and Charles George Herbermann (T-H-L) died in 1916. Oh, and no need to buy the Catholic Encyclopedia, the full text is available online on multiple platforms including wikisource.Hello Fiveby - while I had found a source online several months ago referencing the Christian Community being mentioned in the Catholic Encyclopedia, I should have bought or further sought an original Encyclopedia copy to fully verify this specific edit, and I do apologize if I incorrectly cited this specific reference.
[...]
SamwiseGSix (talk) 17:23, 11 January 2024 (UTC)
SamwiseGSix seems to be engaged in whitewashing Anthroposophy (T-H-L) in general and Rudolf Steiner (T-H-L)'s racism in particular.
See:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?ti ... hroposophy
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?ti ... WP:V_means